Director D.J. Caruso takes on a monumental task with Netflix’s original film, Mary, featuring an all-star cast, including Anthony Hopkins, Noa Cohen, and Stephanie Nur. As Christmas nears, the story of Jesus’ birth is revisited, a tale that has been adapted countless times for the screen, with Mary being the latest iteration.
Cohen shines as Mary, in a movie that explores the pivotal moments before and after she discovers her life’s purpose. By framing Mary’s story as a “coming-of-age” tale, the movie offers a refreshing spin on a familiar narrative. Considering adding this movie to your watchlist? Check out our review!
Noa Cohen’s Stellar Performance Isn’t Enough
Initially, the movie presents an almost Gen-Z spin on the classic tale, evident in the bold opening line: “You may think you know my story. Trust me, you don’t.” While this fresh take deviates from traditional adaptations, it’s not necessarily a bad thing… yet. However, the dialogue may not be the movie’s strongest suit.

The movie opens with Mary’s parents in fervent prayer, taking the audience on a journey back in time. Over the next 1 hour and 50 minutes, patience is required, as the pace of Mary unfolds at a deliberate speed. At times, the movie may feel like background viewing, but for those invested in the subject matter, it’s likely to hold their attention.
Mary strives to be a compelling coming-of-age story, and it seldom succeeds, but despite its focus on the protagonist’s early life and struggles, something feels missing. Unfortunately, these gaps are never filled, leaving Mary to become an underwhelming experience.

Although the film is titled Mary, the coming-of-age aspect of her story is surprisingly understated, deviating from the narrative’s core purpose. Despite the cast’s valiant efforts to bring the story to life, their performances alone can’t carry the entire movie. Cohen’s efforts are particularly noticeable, but even her strong performance can’t compensate for the story’s shortcomings.
Mary falls just above subpar as a cinematic experience, redeemed somewhat by its visually impressive moments. The movie’s set and costume design are notable highlights, making it a pleasure to watch at times.
However, the lack of intensity and a compelling premise ultimately make for a disappointing viewing experience. there was far too much untapped potential, and that was evident from start to finish.

Conclusion
If you’re eager to see another interpretation of a familiar tale, Noa Cohen‘s performance as the movie is certainly worth watching. Although the film tells the story of Jesus’ mother, it ultimately falls short of its potential. Unfortunately, this missed opportunity makes Mary a skippable addition to the numerous adaptations of this iconic story.